When the Cold War ended in 1991 after the Soviet Union disintegrated, it was a glorious moment to be a multilateralist and liberal democrat. It seemed like the whole world wanted to become a democracy and join the democratic community of states. Today, great power competition is back with many describing our present era as a “New Cold War” between the United States and China and Russia. How did the international system go from euphoria about democracy, globalization, the West, and the United States three decades ago, to uncertainty about democracy, doubt about the liberal international order, and fear about the rise of illiberal great powers? Moreover, is the Cold War label an illuminating or distorting analogy, and how stable or enduring is this current moment of global confrontation?
This course seeks to analyze contemporary great power relations. We will begin by reviewing the major theories explaining relations between great powers. The second part of the course traces the historical origins of the U.S.-Russia and U.S.-China relations, examining the interplay between three central drivers of international relations – power, regime types, and leaders – over time. In the third part of the course, we will assess the similarities and differences between the Cold War and U.S.-Russia relations and U.S.-China relations today along three dimensions over the international system: (1) power, (2) ideology, and (3) competing conceptions of global order. The fourth and final part of the course will discuss a set of concrete policy recommendations for how U.S. leaders can meet the challenge of great power competition in the 21st century.
The main text for this course will be a new book in draft by Professor McFaul tentatively called Democrats versus Autocrats: Lessons from the Cold War for Competing with China and Russia Today, as well as accompanying academic books and articles.